Look through our alphabetical list of categories

Italian Restaurants in Garden City, NY

Updated Oct 05 2014 06:49 PM EST with 32 listings
Italian restaurants are famous for their wide variety of pasta dishes and pizzas. They also offer creamy tiramisus and canoli desserts.
Italian Restaurants in Garden City, NY

Italian Restaurants (31 listings total)

Benny's Ristorante

The Northern Italian cuisine is marvelous and consistent - Zagats 2003 Long Island Restaurants
199 Post Ave., Westbury NY (Maple Ave.), Tel 516-997-8111

Bertucci's Brick Oven Pizzeria

Like the original pizzerias and trattorias of Italy, Bertucci's started as a place for friends, family and neighbors to gather. Carryout and sit down dining
Website: bertuccis.com

Bertucci's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Westbury

795 Merrick Ave., Westbury NY 11590 Tel 516-683-8800

Cafe Formaggio

Wonderful Italian food with a varied menu.
307 Old Country Rd., Carle Place NY 11514 Tel 516-333-1718
Fax: 516-334-5834; Website: cafeformaggio.com

Caffe Baci

One of LI's most popular, casual restaurants, serving northern Italian cuisine.
1636 Old Country Rd., Westbury NY 11590 Tel 516-832-8888

Ciao Baby

246 Voice Rd., Carle Place NY 11514 Tel 516-248-7600
Fax: 516-248-2254

Cinelli's Pizzeria

Long Island NY pizzeria and Italian restaurant, leading independent delivery system providing quality, service, & innovation
E-mail: info@cinellis.com; Website: cinellis-ny.com

Fianei's Paninoteca Italiana

150 Seventh St., Garden City NY 11530 Tel 516-741-3582
Fax: 516-741-3597; E-mail: paninotecagc@verizon.net

Galleria Dominick

Wonderful Italian fare featuring excellent fish
238 Post Ave., Westbury NY Tel 516-997-7373

Giulio Cesare Ristorante

Fabulous food including excellent pastas - Zagats 2003 Long Island Restaurants
18 Ellison Ave., Westbury NY (Old Country Rd.), Tel 516-334-2982


Hempstead Long Island NY pizzeria and Italian restaurant
980 Franklin Ave., Garden City NY 11530 Tel 516-294-6565
Website: grimaldisrestaurant.com

Grimaldi's Pizzeria

980 Franklin Ave., Garden City NY 11530 Tel 516-294-6565
Fax: 516-294-0370; E-mail: rjlovers@aol.com
Website: grimmaldisrestaurant.com

Junior's Pizza

Pizza and Italian specialties; salads, entrees, pastas, order by phone or online.
Website: juniorsli.com

La Bottega

Garden City NY 11530 La Bottega is an Italian Restaurant known for their excellent paninis including gluten free. They serve many variations of this Italian sandwich with pasta, salads, wine, espresso, cappuccino, and desserts. Located in the Roosevelt Field Mall, 2nd Floor between Nordstrom and Macy's.
630 Old Country Rd, Garden City NY 11530 Tel 516-248-4529
Website: www.labottegarooseveltfield.com

Lucky Duck

Specializing in large, steaming hot bowls of pasta at reasonable prices.
9 Nassau Blvd., Garden City NY 11530 at Cambridge Rd., Tel 516-485-4848

Mario's Pizza

High quality food made with the finest ingredients, personalized service, unsurpassed value and the traditions of long ago
Website: mariospizzaonline.com

Mario's Pizza - Westbury

596 Old Country Road, Westbury NY 11590 Tel 516-997-3000

Mario's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Restaurant combines old-world charm with modern-day culinary masterpieces for a unique experience. Or indulge in steaming hot pizza at home, convenient takeout and delivery services
Website: mariospizzeria.com

Papa Razzi

Good, fast Italian cuisine
1500 Jericho Tpk., Westbury NY 11590 (Guinea Woods Rd.), Tel 516-877-7744


Excellent Italian food famous for its tomatoes and sauce; catering, parties, and special events welcome.
All Long Island NY
Website: pomodorino.com


Pizzas, paninis, home-made soups and pastas. by Newsday
221 Old Country Rd., Carle Place NY 11514 Tel 516-248-1004


Attractive, homelike setting - Zagats 2003 Long Island Restaurant
588 Westbury Ave., Carle Place NY 11514 Tel 516-997-5283


Fresh, traditional Italian cuisine serving famous pizza, delicious seafood, vegetable pastas, salads, sandwiches, and homemade desserts in a casual atmosphere
Tel 800-456-4837
Website: www.sbarro.com

Seventh St. Cafe

Popular pasta palace in Garden City, serving delicious Northern Italian dishes made from fresh ingredients in casual elegance
126 7th St., Garden City NY 11530 Tel 516-747-7575
Website: seventhstreetcafe.com

Steve's Piccola Bussola

Featuring fantastic pastas and veal dishes that steal the show - Zagats 2003 Long Island Restaurants
649 Old Country Rd., Westbury NY 11568 Tel 516-333-1335


Great, regional Italian cuisine; casual comfort & friendly service.
967 Old Country Rd., Westbury NY 11590 Tel 516-334-0022

Umberto's of Garden City

Garden City Long Island NY pizzeria & Italian restaurant, delivery available
361 Nassau Blvd. South, Garden City NY 11530 Tel 516-481-1279

Umberto's Pizzeria of New Hyde Park

Classic Italian favorites
Mall at the Source Old Country Rd, Westbury NY 11590 food court, Tel 516-228-1306

Venere Ristorante

Pastas and outstanding veal chop house specialty - Zagats 2003 Long Island Restaurants
841 Carman Ave., Westbury NY 11590 1/4m S of Old Country Rd, Tel 516-333-2332

Vincent's Clam Bar

Seafood and pasta restaurant that preserve the old world atmosphere of "Little Italy"
179 Old Country Rd., Carle Place NY Tel 516-742-4577
Fax: 516-742-4579; Website: vincentsclaimbar.com

Sicilian Restaurants (1 listings total)

Ciao Baby

Long Island New York Italian restaurants very well reviewed catering homemade fresh mozerella eggplant rollatini calamari baked clams Sicilian rice balls shrimp scampi tuna italian spring rolls and much more
Website: caiobabyrestaurant.com